- November 16, 2026
- Posted by: Colm Hurley
- Category: News
In this article, Grace Ryan, Solicitor, and Ross Cudmore, Trainee Solicitor, examine High Court’s inherent jurisdiction and outline the key implications of the recent High Court decision in HSE v A.M. [2026] IEHC 190 for practitioners, families and professionals.
Background
The Respondent, a 62-year-old woman, had been subject to High Court Orders since 2024 and, on foot of the detention orders granted, she had been placed in a nursing home. At the time, these orders were grounded on medical evidence that diagnosed the respondent with a neurodegenerative disease known as behavioural variant frontotemporal dementia (bvFTD).
However, after the Respondent began residing in the nursing home, new medical evidence began to suggest the diagnosis was incorrect.
The Court was therefore required to reassess not only whether the Respondent lacked capacity, but also whether continued intervention under the Court’s inherent jurisdiction remained justified and proportionate, noting that the High Court’s inherent jurisdiction is exceptional and limited.
While in the nursing home, the Respondent consistently expressed the desire to return home to live with her daughter rather than continue to stay in the nursing home, which typically catered to a clientele much older than the Respondent.
Medical Evidence
The matter was brought before the Court for review and the Court considered evidence from three psychiatrists. While there was consensus that the Respondent did not suffer from bvFTD, there were conflicting views on whether the Respondent’s psychological history affected her ability to make decisions.
The psychiatrist considered that the Respondent was able to understand, retain, weigh and communicate information.
The Court acknowledged that the Respondent did have the ability to understand, retain and communicate information. However, the Court considered more persuasive the evidence from the doctors who found that the respondent lacked the capacity to weigh information in relation to returning home to live with her daughter. The Court noted that the Respondent was unable to contemplate the possibility that her daughter might not support her returning home and that there may be difficulties in relation to the daughter’s partner. The Court found that this omission in the decision-making process demonstrated an inability to weigh the risks of returning home.
As well as carefully considering the medical evidence, Mr Justice O’Donnell met personally with the Respondent as part of the decision-making process, so as to better understand her perspective and wishes, as well as to see how she processed information.
The Test
The Court emphasised that capacity is decision-specific and must be assessed by reference to the particular decision in question.
Importantly, merely making an unwise decision is not by itself evidence of a lack of capacity. The question is whether the Respondent is able to properly consider and weigh the information relevant to the decision.
The issue at hand was not whether the Respondent’s decision to return home was unwise. The question was whether the respondent was capable of properly considering and weighing the information relevant to that decision.
Judgment
The Court found that the Respondent lacked capacity to decide whether to return home as a result of psychological difficulties, which affected her ability to weigh the risks of such a decision. The Court also found that at present the respondent lacks capacity to make major or complex financial decisions.
However, the Court placed limits on the continued use of its inherent jurisdiction. The existing orders were continued only on a short-term basis to facilitate the Respondent’s transfer to a step-down placement, an open facility closer to the Respondent’s home. This was a less restrictive arrangement and reflects the need for proportionality when the Court interferes with the Respondent’s liberty.
Key Implications
For Practitioners, there are several important points to take away.
- Capacity assessments should be functional and decision-specific.
Evidence that a person can understand, retain and communicate information may not adequately address the question of whether they can use or weigh that information when making the particular decision.
- Inherent jurisdiction orders require ongoing justification.
Inherent jurisdiction orders should not continue indefinitely merely because a person has previously been found to lack capacity. Their continuation requires an ongoing justification. Where detention is no longer necessary, the Court indicated that decision-making should instead be addressed under the Assisted Decision-Making (Capacity) Act 2015.
- A precise diagnosis is not required for the Court to exercise its inherent jurisdiction.
The Court’s focus is on whether there is satisfactory evidence that the person lacks capacity to make the particular decision, not whether the respondent has received an exact diagnosis.
Conclusion
Health Service Executive v A.M. provides useful clarification of the approach to functional capacity in the context of inherent jurisdiction proceedings. The judgment reinforces that capacity is decision-specific and cannot be determined simply by reference to diagnosis, vulnerability or the apparent wisdom of a proposed decision.
For practitioners, families, and services, this decision provides guidance on how the Court will seek to balance protection with empowerment when assisting adults with diminished capacity.